SERE staff were required undergo the waterboard at its fullest. Officers of the armed forces and all active members of US military and US government and US state governments are required by oath to obey and defend the Constitution and thus the people of the United States. Drowning in Questions – Newsweek Magazine. Well let’s just leave Ms. Your position of a purported moral high ground yields the field to those who wish us ill. But we are fighting against men who use brutal tactics. They may believe it is so; but that does not make it so.
Mr Evans, in response, 1. However, the closer you get to the center of the storm, the more gray things become. I also respect your opinion in this matter even moreso now. Buddy, you are as wrong as the day is long. I believe that we are a great nation, and that we should treat others humanely. The carnival-like he-said, she-said of the legality of Enhanced Interrogation Techniques has become a form of doublespeak worthy of Catch
The threat of torture juxtaposed with the promise of humane treatment and privileges in exchange for cooperation. In fact I have a copy of it here on my desk, next to the Bible, the Torah, the Constitution, the Declaration of Independence, and the Federalist Papers.
Everything before this date was different and for the most part terrorism was something that occurred only in countries far away from America. Nice use of the Rumsfeld scare tactic. Name one major success derived strictly from information obtained via waterboarding – this conflict was supposed to have been aboutthose responsible for financing and planning the attacks are still free and remain a significant waterboarring. Both the CIA esday the Pentagon deny the allegation.
Then go to http: Historically the United States is very opposed to torture with treaties like the Convention Against Torture, a known reputation for taking in illegal aliens who are victims of torture in their own country, and criminalizes any known party that participates in torture Luban.
If you want consistent, accurate and reliable intelligence, be inquisitive, analytical, patient but most of all professional, amiable and compassionate.
Evans, with the help of people like you, the current American administration is turning us into them. Once the improbable is deemed morally irrelevant, torture can no longer claim the status of absolute wrong, for there is no such thing as an “absolute-wrong-in-practice. What reaction would the military get if it did? The goal of these people is to destroy us and our way of life, by ANY means neccessary. People have been convicted and sent to prison for slashing people’s throats, raping people’s wives, BUT America has not tortured those people.
To many, its abhorrence requires no empirical evidence: CWO Wright, This is what I hate about these online chat-posting-blog forums, lack of familiarity and context. They remain oddly silent on whether, say, the Taliban would be entitled to torture captured American soldiers thought to know about imminent drone attacks.
IFTF: From torture to persuasion
I do not love the enemy – and I am offended by the accusations coming from Republicans such as your ridiculous accusation that, “either you support Torture, or you love the enemy”.
These people give everything up like someone on a waterboard, but while comfortably seated at their keyboards. The echo chamber that is the American media now views torture as a heroic and macho. Believe me, I’m not the kind of guy who goes around picking fights for no reason, and I find myself reluctantly accepting the fact that something like waterboarding may be a necessary evil.
Persuasive Essay | Miranda Byrne’s E-Portfolio
In your first post you implied that we persuasice justified in our torture because these men intend to break into our homes and kill our families. The CIA maintains it only subjected three detainees to waterboarding. Whether on a board or on the floor, they induced near suffocation using water.
Let me ask you something. The quickest way to harden them against us is to leave them no choice about which side to take. I was however, a little annoyed at some wssay other reasons the author gave for not engaging in waterboarding, reasons I felt were irrelevent and only give Americans a false sense of their own non-existent moral leadership in the world.
TBS advocates often lack the courtesy to grant the same rights to their enemies. S hould torture be legalized in exceptional circumstances? On a Mekong River trip, I met a year-old man, happy to be alive and a cheerful travel companion, who survived waterboardijg genocide and torture Unless you have been strapped down to the board, have endured the agonizing feeling of the water overpowering your gag reflex, and then feel your throat open and allow pint after pint of water to involuntarily fill your lungs, you will not know the meaning of the word.
Torture by another name: CIA used ‘water dousing’ on at least 12 detainees
But that can be dangerous: You’re not helping anyone, least of all this discussion, O Noble Patriot. This criticism does not include the many fine contributions by contemporary moral philosophers and legal theorists. University of South Florida psychologist and terrorism expert Dr.
Even worse, the administration has selectively leaked supposed successes of the water board such as the alleged Khalid Sheik Mohammed confessions. If morality is going to be incapable of helping us decide, then our choice should engage us fully so as to avoid persuasivr rationalization.